r.e.m. beauty Wicked: For Good Makeup Set review

Intro

This r.e.m. beauty Wicked: For Good makeup set ships four full-size pieces in an Elphaba-inspired color story: a listed waterproof forest-green liquid eyeshadow, an all-over glow/highlight stick, a creamy lip liner, and a shimmering glossy balm. The listing frames this as a themed, Ariana Grande–adjacent collection, and owners repeatedly praise the pigmentation, the waterproof wear of the eyeshadow, and the overall gift-ready vibe. If you want a themed, ready-to-gift bundle that skews bold and a little sparkly, this is the sort of set people are buying and enjoying.

What it is / first look

The set is sold as four full-size products and is described in the listing as the r.e.m. beauty x Wicked: For Good collection. The named pieces and shades in the package are:

• Elphie — a lustrous forest green liquid/metallic eyeshadow with a golden shift (listed).
• Braverism — a deep berry-plum lip & cheek stick (listed).
• Defy Expectations — a warm chocolate-brown creamy lip liner (listed).
• Wickedness — a warm brown glossy balm with gold and plum shimmer (listed).

The product packaging and the theme are a consistent selling point in owner notes: multiple buyers call the Wicked/Elphaba packaging "cute" and specifically say they purchased as fans of the Wicked collection or Ariana Grande’s brand collaboration. The listing size and weight for the package are 7.48 x 6.34 x 1.73 inches and 7.05 ounces, which describes the shipped product dimensions rather than individual tube sizes.

Who this is a good gift for

Be specific: this is a themed makeup set that leans sparkly and statement-making. Below are practical recipient matches and the assumptions you should check before buying.

The Wicked/Ariana Grande fan

• Why it fits: The listing calls this the r.e.m. beauty x Wicked collection and owner feedback specifically mentions people buying it because they loved the Wicked packaging or Ariana Grande connection.
• Assumption to check: the recipient likes themed or branded beauty drops rather than plain, neutral packaging.

The person who likes bold or duochrome eyeshadows

• Why it fits: the Elphie eyeshadow is listed as a forest green with a golden shift and multiple owners praise the metallic/duochrome finish and pigment.
• Assumption to check: they want statement eyes rather than only neutral browns.

The makeup-gift-for-teen or tween (with caution)

• Why it fits: owners report buying this as a gift for an 11-year-old granddaughter and call it a "great girls gift," so some buyers are comfortable gifting it to younger teens.
• Assumption to check: you know the recipient’s parents’ limits, and you're comfortable gifting makeup to that age. The listing does not provide an official age recommendation.

The quick-glam everyday user who likes low-effort products

• Why it fits: buyer notes call the products highly pigmented and easy to use for quick looks — notably the liquid eyeshadow and the glow stick make quick application simple.
• Assumption to check: they prefer pigmented, visible makeup and don't mind shimmer/glitter.

The person who treats makeup as a novelty/collectible

• Why it fits: the branded theme and collectible feel make this appealing for someone who enjoys limited-run or collab releases.
• Assumption to check: the recipient appreciates novelty collabs and themed packaging rather than purely utility-focused gifts.

In daily use

Owners provide the clearest picture of how these products behave day-to-day. Pulling together repeated feedback produces three reliable patterns: the eyeshadow performs like a long-wear, waterproof shimmer; the glow stick reads sparkly rather than subtle; and the lip pair is comfortable and versatile.

Eyeshadow (Elphie)

• Wear and hold: The listing describes the eyeshadow as a forest-green liquid shadow with shift, and owners repeatedly praise its staying power. Several buyers say it "stayed put all night" and that it didn’t crease on oily lids — a useful signal if the recipient struggles with transfer or creasing.
• Removal and intensity: Owners also describe it as highly pigmented and metallic; one reviewer notes that the metallic eyeshadow "does not transfer and has a beautiful shine" and that it can resist water without budging unless you use a makeup remover or significant scrubbing.

All-over glow stick

• Finish: Multiple owners call the highlight stick "pretty" but emphasize it's "definitely on the glittery side." If your gift recipient prefers understated, blurred glow, this is a key detail — the product is clearly intended to sparkle.
• Use cases: Owners suggest keeping it for going-out looks rather than a very subtle everyday highlight due to the glitter level.

Lip liner and glossy balm

• Lip liner: The creamy lip liner (Defy Expectations) gets consistent praise as a "your lips but better" shade that pairs easily with the included gloss and other lip colors.
• Gloss: Owners describe the glossy balm (Wickedness) as comfortable and "not sticky," and several comments specifically mention the scent as a plus — "smells amazing." That means fragrance is likely noticeable to users.

Overall routine fit

For most owners, the set covers a quick, full look: single-step eye intensity from the liquid shadow, a combined lip-and-cheek stick for color, a liner to shape, and a finishing glossy balm. That combination is convenient for gift buyers wanting a compact, ready-to-use kit without extra tools.

Materials & build quality

Listing detail is limited on formulation and packaging materials. The product is presented and packaged as a themed set in a compact box (package dimensions given), and owners consistently call the packaging attractive. The listing and owner notes do not enumerate tube materials, ingredient lists, or whether any items are housed in recyclable packaging.

What we do know from the listing and owner feedback:

• The set includes four full-size items (stated in the title).
• The shade names and color descriptions come from the listing: Elphie (forest green with gold shift), Braverism (deep berry plum), Defy Expectations (warm chocolate brown liner), Wickedness (warm brown gloss with gold & plum shimmer).
• Owners call the makeup "highly pigmented," "lightweight," and "beautifully soft but bright enough," which indicates perceived formula quality in use.

Because the listing does not specify materials or ingredient claims, verify current ingredient/ formulation information on the seller or manufacturer page if the recipient has allergies, sensitivities, or packaging/disposal preferences.

Safety considerations

Safety is mostly about formulation sensitivity and how the product behaves on skin and around eyes. The listing does not provide ingredient or certification details, so rely on owner reports and the listing descriptions when evaluating risk.

Key signals to weigh

• Glitter content: Owners repeatedly note the highlight is "on the glittery side." If the recipient has sensitive skin, is prone to eye irritation, or dislikes glitter, this is a meaningful red flag.
• Waterproof wear and removal: The eyeshadow is described as waterproof in the listing and owners say it resists water and stays put "all night" and "with almost no budge under water without makeup remover or serious scrubbing." Long-wear, waterproof makeup can require oil-based removers or double-cleansing routines to avoid tugging at the skin; factor that in for someone who prioritizes gentle removal.
• Fragrance: Several owners mention the gloss "smells amazing," which indicates fragrance is perceptible. If the recipient is fragrance-sensitive, check ingredients because the listing does not specify perfume or fragrance-free status.
• Age and appropriateness: While owners report buying it for an 11-year-old granddaughter, the listing does not specify an age recommendation. If buying for a child or tween, confirm parental comfort and any safety/allergy concerns.

Given the missing ingredient list and any official safety certifications, the safest move for high-sensitivity recipients is to verify the current product page or packaging for allergen and ingredient information before gifting.

Who should skip it

• Anyone who hates shimmer or glitter — the highlight stick is explicitly called glittery by owners and the glossy balm includes shimmer in its description.
• People who need fragrance-free products — owner comments about scent suggest the gloss has a noticeable smell and the listing is silent on fragrance claims.
• Makeup minimalists who want neutral, understated palettes — this set leans into bold green duochrome and richer earth tones rather than plain, muted neutrals.
• Anyone with active sensitivities who needs documented ingredient transparency — the listing does not provide an ingredient list, so if the recipient requires hypoallergenic or dermatologist-tested claims, this listing doesn’t provide that information directly.

Verdict

r.e.m. beauty’s Wicked: For Good set is a themed, full-size four-piece kit that does what the listing promises: it delivers a statement green shimmer shadow (listed as waterproof), a glitter-forward glow stick, a versatile liner, and a comfortable glossy balm. Owners repeatedly praise the pigmentation, the eyeshadow’s long-wear and non-creasing behavior even on oily lids, and the gloss’s comfort and scent. The set is clearly a crowd-pleaser for fans of the collab packaging and for people who like dramatic, glowy looks.

That said, the listing lacks ingredient and material detail, and owners flag the highlight’s glitter and the gloss’s scent — two things to check if your recipient has sensitivities or dislikes fragrance and sparkle. For a fan of the theme or someone who enjoys bold, long-wear makeup, this is a safe, giftable pick. For someone who prefers subtle, fragrance-free, or ingredient-documented items, it’s worth pausing and verifying those specifics first.

Check before you buy

• Confirm the current ingredient list and any fragrance or allergen notes on the manufacturer page if the recipient has skin sensitivities.
• Verify the recipient is comfortable with visible glitter and shimmer (the highlight is described by owners as glittery).
• Decide if the recipient values themed/celebrity-collab packaging — multiple owners bought for that reason.
• Double-check any age considerations with parents/guardians if you plan to gift this to a tween; the listing does not provide an age recommendation despite owner reports of gifting to an 11-year-old.
• Check return and exchange policies in case a shade doesn’t suit the recipient’s skin tone preferences.