Reviews: black eyeliner

Makeup

Kiko Milano Smoky Eye Pencil | Soft And Highly Blendable Pencil For The Lash Line

A soft, blendable lash-line pencil that reads intense black and is ophthalmologically tested. Good low-cost pick with mixed notes on longevity and sharpening.

91.1 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.4★	+88.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Small but useful crowd	+0.7 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	68/100	+0.7 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	66/100	+0.6 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		91.1

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

tarte tartelette quick stick liner – Ultra-Thin Slanted Tip Gel Eyeliner for Precision, Waterproof Eye Makeup, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, full size

A compact, click-to-advance gel liner with a slanted 1.3mm tip. The listing promises waterproof, long-wearing color and contact-lens safety; owners praise precision and wear but some report crumbling.

88.9 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.3★	+86.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Healthy review crowd	+0.8 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Moderate	-1.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		88.9

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Lord & Berry SILK KAJAL Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, Long Lasting Soft Gel based Eye Liner for Women With Smudgeable Semi-Matte Finish, Ophthalmologically Tested & Cruelty Free Makeup, Black

A silky, highly pigmented kohl pencil made for the waterline; owners praise pigment and comfort, but there are repeated notes about melting in heat and occasional damaged arrival.

92.0 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.4★	+88.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.5 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Minor	-0.6 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	76/100	+1.0 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		92.0

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Smashbox Always On Liquid 24-Hour Eye Liner | Long Lasting + Waterproof with Dramatic Precision, Black, 0.02 Ounce

A precision felt-tip liquid liner that the listing claims will stay put for 24 hours. Owners praise its long-wear and pigment but some report early drying.

90.0 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.3★	+86.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.6 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Moderate	-0.7 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	76/100	+1.0 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		90.0

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner | 24-Hour Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil for Long-Lasting, Pigment-Rich Color | Gel Liner for Eye Makeup and Waterline

A waterproof gel pencil that promises 24-hour wear and intense pigment. Owners praise its staying power but warn about sharpening and removal issues—good for anyone who values long-lasting liner.

94.0 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.8 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Moderate	-1.2 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	80/100	+1.2 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		94.0

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

tarte sex kitten liquid liner – Liquid Eyeliner Pen with Castor Oil for Bold, Nourished Lashes, Waterproof, All-Day Wear, Easy to Apply, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, full size, black

A slim felt-tip liquid liner that promises bold, long-wearing black lines and lists castor oil for lash-nourishing. Owners love the pigment and precision; some report smudging in humidity.

94.0 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.9 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Moderate	-1.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	70/100	+0.8 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		94.0

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner | Smudge-Proof, Waterproof Eyeliner | Precise 8-Hour Wear Liner For Everyday And Dramatic Eye Looks

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner in 05 Black Ink is a compact, cream-to-set gel liner that the listing calls waterproof and long-wear; owners praise its smudge resistance but a minority report the pot can dry out.

92.5 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.4★	+88.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Minor	-0.6 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	80/100	+1.2 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	70/100	+0.8 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		92.5

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Lancôme Le Crayon Khol - Creamy - Blendable - Long-Wearing Eye Pencil

A luxury-brand kohl pencil that owners praise for creamy application and day-long wear; good as a thoughtful, low-fuss makeup gift if the recipient likes classic eyeliners.

97.5 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.6★	+92.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	80/100	+1.2 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	82/100	+1.3 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	80/100	+1.2 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		97.5

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

IT Cosmetics Superhero Liquid Eyeliner Pen, Black - 24-Hour Waterproof Formula Won’t Smudge or Fade - With Peptides, Collagen, Biotin & Kaolin Clay - 0.03 fl oz

A waterproof liquid eyeliner with a brush-hair tip and lash-loving additives. Owners praise long wear but note oily lids and lack of shadow can affect smudge resistance.

97.5 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.6★	+92.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	79/100	+1.2 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	81/100	+1.2 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		97.5

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Urban Decay Perversion Waterproof Black Liquid Eyeliner - Smudge-Proof, Sweat-Proof, Transfer-Resistant, Fine-Point Eye Pen, Flexible Brush Tip, Semi-Matte Black, Precise Application, Vegan

Urban Decay Perversion is a waterproof, semi-matte black liquid eyeliner with a fine, flexible brush tip. Owners praise the pigment and wear but commonly report tip fraying and late-day flaking.

97.0 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.6★	+92.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	70/100	+0.8 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		97.0

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read